Colangelo made an immediate impact in her debut season, becoming the only first-year player named to the All-Conference First Team.
She posted a 13-2 overall record, went 6-1 in Landmark play, and ranked second in the league with a 1.20 earned run average. Her 30 strikeouts were the fifth-most in conference action. Colangelo is the third Cardinal to earn Landmark Rookie of the Year honors—and the second in as many seasons, following Mia Szap's selection in 2024.