Cunningham had a 2-0 week in the circle to help Moravian to a 3-1 week as the Greyhounds clinched the top seed in the 2023 Landmark Conference Tournament. Cunningham posted a 0.78 ERA with nine strikeouts and just one walk allowed in 18 innings of action. She earned the win in Moravian's 5-0 shutout win over Juniata, and Cunningham tossed all 11 innings in a 6-5, 11-inning victory over Drew to clinch the top seed.